The Law Society have updated their guidance on VAT on disbursements and expenses as per the practice note below. We have tried to summarise this below, but please familiarise yourself with the practice note in full:
It will have an effect on the way that client bills should be presented and accounts payables are posted in relation to input VAT.
Essentially HMRC argue that VAT should be charged on some non vatable payments such as searches, as they should be treated as an expense for VAT purposes under some circumstances.
What is the difference between a disbursement and an expense?
Essentially a cost incurred by a Solicitor should be treated as either (1) an expense or (2) a disbursement. (1) An expense should always have VAT charged upon it and forms part of the solicitors service. (2) A disbursement may be passed on without charging output VAT and is a third party cost for the benefit of the client. A disbursement must meet a strict criteria as outlined by HMRC below.
The defining factor for determining whether a payment qualifies as a disbursement for VAT purposes is whether its reimbursement by the client is part of the consideration for the “service supplied by you”, or whether it is made for third-party services supplied to your client.
It is important to note that if you are not charged VAT by a supplier on an item or an expense it does not necessarily mean that you do not need to charge VAT to the client. The description given to a payment is not relevant for determining whether it can be treated as a disbursement for VAT purposes. The key question is whether the reimbursement forms part of the consideration for the “service supplied by you”.
When can a payment be treated as a disbursement for VAT purposes?
“You may treat a payment to a third party as a disbursement for VAT purposes if all the following conditions are met:
HMRC’s view is that all the conditions set out above must be satisfied before a payment can be treated as a disbursement for VAT purposes.
This view, specifically in relation to electronic property searches, is set out in full in HMRC’s internal manual VAT Taxable Person at 47000 which states:
VAT on search fees
HMRC is of the view that where a solicitor has used the search to provide further advice to the client, it is considered integral to the solicitor’s legal supply and therefore cannot be treated as a disbursement. This means that you will have to charge VAT when you charge this cost to the client. This increases the cost to the client where the search fees are not subject to VAT.
Where an administration fee is incurred in relation to search fees, this should be treated as an expense if recharged to a client as it forms part of the service supplied.
VAT on Land Registry fees
Land Registry fees can be broadly divided into three categories:
The Land Registry does not charge VAT on its fees.
It is the Law Society view that it should ordinarily be possible for registration fees to be treated as a disbursement.
Local Land Charge Search fees
HMRC’s view is that fees for ‘local authority’ searches that you have used as part of your advice in a transaction are subject to VAT when you charge them to your client.
It is important to consider whether the solicitor has used or commented on a search, medical report, etc, which should therefore form part of the service provided – And be treated as an expense for VAT purposes, attracting VAT – Rather than as a disbursement.
As we are not involved in the majority of bill preparation, it is important for your solicitors to be aware of the above and charge the correct output rate of VAT on client billing and also ensure that the expense/disbursement is correctly displayed on the client bill. Please forward this onto solicitors within your team.
The information above and in the Law Society practice note is only guidance and it is upto each legal practice to interpret.
For further advice or consultancy, please get in touch with us at email@example.com or 03333 441 654
“...I have found them very knowledgeable and full of expertise In Legal Aid, Inter partes and High costs cases.
They are always at the end of the phone or email if myself or anyone else in the firm have a billing enquiry and would highly recommend them to any legal firm
“Having instructed Bidwell Henderson since they formed in 2014, I can say with enormous confidence that their Costs Draftsmen are the most knowledgeable, efficient and friendly Costs Draftsmen I have had the pleasure of working with.”
“KK Law have used many cost draftsman firms within the last 10 years but have finally found the firm that is the right fit for us ”
Their service is professional, efficient, accurate and they turn our files around quickly. The Admin, accounts and cost draftsman team are all friendly and knowledgeable.
I would not hesitate to recommend Bidwell Henderson to anyone in the legal profession, they have always gone the extra mile on all of our cases both standard and complex to help expedite our bill payment.
“I would have no hesitation in recommending their drafting and processing services.”
As one of our key strategic partners we have found Bidwell Henderson to be a very forward thinking and highly professional law costs drafting firm. They should be commended on their continual investment in staff training, quality controls and GDPR principles.
Specialising in billing through Tikit P4W they fit with our services portfolio perfectly. They consistently hit the mark first time – demonstrating the quality of their work and professionalism of their team, whilst more importantly improving client cashflow.
“The Bidwell Henderson team are an absolute pleasure to deal with”
The Bidwell Henderson team are an absolute pleasure to deal with as they are all so helpful and accommodating and deliver client focused services to suit business needs.
In addition to providing an efficient, tailored and exceptionally pro-active service – they strike the perfect balance of friendly and professional.
“I have been practicing for almost 20 years and without a doubt Bidwell Henderson are the best cost lawyers and draftsmen I have ever instructed”
I have always found their managers and draftsmen to have detailed knowledge of current costs’ law, our case management system and to be knowledgeable and personable.
The managers Ann Henderson and Rebecca Bidwell are always on hand to support their cost draftsmen, and their strategic knowledge of how to manage the Legal Aid Agency costing process is invaluable and impressive.